We Asked, You Said, We Did

Below are some of the topics we have recently consulted on and their outcomes.

We Asked

What rent level increase you preferred for 2020/21 out of three options:

3.5%

4%

4.5%

You Said

A total of 1,251 tenants responded to the Rent Level Options 2020/21 consultation. 

The results are:

Option 1 - 3.5% increase: 708 votes (56.59%)

Option 2 - 4% increase: 397 votes (31.73%)

Option 3: 4% increase: 146 votes (11.67%)

Therefore, Option 1, a 3.5% increase, was the preferred option.

We Did

These results of the consultation were included in a report to Housing and Communities Committee on January 29th 2020, when the rent levels for 2020/21 were set.

The Committee agreed a 3.5% rent rise for 2020/21, in line with the views of tenants. This will keep rents affordable whilst allowing us to make the investments in Housing Services that tenants have told us they want. The rent increase will come into effect from April 2020. 

 

 

We Asked

We consulted members of the public, organisations and businesses about CCTV provision. 

  1. Are you aware of CCTV?
  2. Does CCTV Reduce Crime & Increase Public Safety?
  3. Does CCTV help to Detect & Investigate Crime?
  4. Clearly Visible CCTV Makes Me Feel Safer in Perth City?
  5. Are You Concerned That CCTV in Perth City Will Affect Your Privacy?
  6. Do You Trust The Police & Council To use CCTV Only Where Necessary & In An Appropriate Manner?
  7. Are You Concerned About The Improvements In Digital CCTV Technology?

You Said

  1. 96% of respondents were either fully or vaguely aware of CCTV
  2. 96% of respondents either strongly agreed or agreed
  3. 98% of respondents either strongly agreed or agreed
  4. 77% of respondents either strongly agreed or agreed
  5. 87% of respondents had no concerns. 11% had concerns. 2% did not know
  6. 78% of respondents trusted he Police &/or Council. 11% did not know. 10% did not trust the Police &/or Council
  7. 69% of respondents had no concerns. 28% had concerns. 3% did not know.

We Did

The results of consultation have been incorporated into the Privacy Impact Assessment on the new CCTV system being installed. The results indicated that the use of CCTV is justifiable and proportionate for its intended purpose.

Other feedback and comments will support any future development of the use of CCTV. 

We Asked

Following the Summer Tenant Conference 2019 where investment in Housing Services was discussed with attendees, we asked the wider tenant population for more detailed information on how you wanted us to invest in your housing services during 2020/21.

You Said

Tenants gave us some further detailed information on their preferences for investment.

We Did

The information you provided fed into the process that produced the three Rent Level Options and investment proposals for 2020/21 that tenants were given the opportunity to vote on in November and December 2019.

We Asked

What tenants' priorities were for investing in Housing Services during 2020/21.

You Said

Areas of high priority for tenants were:

  • Keeping my home well maintained and warm (such as energy efficiency, door entry systems)
  • Improving the maintenance of my neighbourhood (such as fences/boundary walls/bin stores)
  • Increasing the number of council homes for rent in the area
  • Improving the services we provide to older tenants

We Did

We presented the findings to the Summer Tenant Conference in 2019 and asked tenants to drill down further to tell us what their highest priorities were for investment.

The questions we asked tenants at the Conference then went out for further consultation.

The findings were used to come up with the 2020/21 Rent Level Options and investment proposals that were presented to tenants to vote on in November and December 2019.

We Asked

We asked for your views on the potential for secondary provision at a  joint 2-18 community learning campus which could accommodate pupils from Angus, Dundee and Perth & Kinross.

You Said

Of the 243 Perth and Kinross responses, 194 (80%) were supportive of the proposal, 30 (12%) were unsure and 19 (8%) were against the proposal. 

Of the 194 responses in favour of the proposal 85% of parents/carers said they would send their children to the joint 2-18 community learning campus if the proposal was to proceed.

We Did

The following recommendations were agreed at Perth and Kinross Council’s Lifelong Learning Committee on 4 September 2019.

  1. The progress that has been made through collaboration between the three local authorities be noted.
  2. It be noted that the explanatory work that has been undertaken has clarified that the joint 2-18 community learning campus is not the right solution for each authority area at this time.
  3. Agree that the Executive Director (Education and Children’s Services) ceases involvement in the exploration of a joint 2-18 community learning campus at this time and focuses on the improvement of the existing learning estate.
  4. Request the Executive Director to relay the Lifelong Learning Committee’s ongoing commitment to partnership working on innovative collaborative projects related to the learning estate and the learner journey.

We Asked

The Council and Sweco consulted with the community on:

  • The risk of flooding in Comrie
  •  The Council's proposals for a flood scheme
  • Other action to raise awareness of flood risk and improve flood resilience

You Said

The response to the consultation was generally positive with the majority of the community being supportive of the proposed outline design for the flood scheme.

We Did

The public consultation on the outline design is now complete and, where possible, the proposals have been amended to address the concerns raised by the community. The flood scheme will therefore be published under the Flood Risk Management (Scotland) Act in 2020  and the Council will notify all affected landowners and residents at that time.

We Asked

We asked  what you think about the four priorities identified to be included in the Draft Tayside Strategy for Parents 2019-23.

You Said

100% of parents agreed or strongly agreed that the priorities focus on the things that are important to them. You also told us what you thought was working well and identified areas you would like to see improvement. For example:

  • Improved access to information to support parents throughout their parenting journey
  • Improved schools communications to increase parental involvement, particularly focussing on parents of children aged 7 years and above.
  • Creating a consistency of family learning programmes across Tayside.
  • Promoting whole family approaches to assessments and service delivery.
  • Developing training to increase engagement skills and awareness of a range of issues affecting parenting.

We Did

The information informed the development of the Tayside Strategy for Parents 2019-2024 and parents views have been captured  in a short animated video  to promote the strategy  to parents and service providers.

Work has started in relation to developing and delivering an action plan which will address the strategies improvement priorities. A further consultation with parents in Autumn 2019 will help to inform this further.

We Asked

Perth & Kinross Council asked for feedback on the draft Crieff Air Quality Action Plan, asking the public if they agreed or disagreed with 25 proposed air quality improvement measures.

You Said

The majority of feedback the draft Air Quality Action Plan received was positive, with only two questions receiving a negative response, these were:

Question 4: Tell us how much you agree with the measure of rerouting some of the traffic that uses the A85 to use only local roads thus moving traffic away from the area?

Question 10: Tell us how much you agree with the proposed measure of holding/gating traffic as a way of minimising congestion within the AQMA? (Holding the traffic back to allow a better flow).

We Did

The consultation feedback informed the final Crieff Air Quality Action Plan, which was then approved by the Environment and Infrastructure Committee on 21/08/2019.

We Asked

To help us make informed decisions, we asked for opinions on how we could make savings as budgets tighten.  

The public were asked to tell us:

  • how they feel about different service areas.
  • how they would make savings from the Council budget.
  • if they would change Council Tax and by how much.
  • their ideas on how the Council could generate additional income to offset the savings required.

You Said

1085 complete responses were received and considered. The results of the consultation are reported here.

We Did

The consultation feedback was taken into consideration in developing final recommendations which were put to full Council on 20th February 2019. Full Council agreed the Perth & Kinross Council budget for 2019/20.

We Asked

We want BSL users to help us;

  • by testing Contact Scotland
  • with changes to our website
  • with our BSL interpreting and translating guide for staff before any contracts are agreed with BSL Interpreters
  • by telling us which of our staff should be trained first
  • by telling us if the staff training is what you wish it to be
  • by meeting with us at least twice a year to make sure our plan is progressing as you wish  and telling us if it isn’t!

You Said

From 11 June event:

  • Our Plan needs to be written in Plain English
  • More staff need to be trained in BSL
  • More staff need awareness training in BSL and Deaf Culture
  • We need to use BSL qualified interpreters and other support when required for meetings
  • Communication for BSL parents and BSL children needs to be good so parents are more involved
  • Access to jobs and further learning is important
  • We need to improve access to health services
  • BSL users would like to be more included at events and other activities in the local area
  • Local political parties should be doing more for BSL users

We Did

By 28 June event:

  • Met with different people who contacted us to submit their ideas
  • Shared the feedback with Dundee and Angus Councils (and they did the same in their meetings)
  • Our plan was rewritten in Plain English where possible
  • Changed some of the actions in our draft plan to make sure what you have asked us to look at is included

We Asked

The Gypsy/Traveller Community whether they agreed with the proposed themes

You Said

Gypsy/Traveller community members were consulted on the themes and revised actions during July and August with opportunities to comment also made available online.  

Three specific comments were received from community members relating to (i) the lack of a bus stop near the Gairney Bridge/Greenacres site in Kinross;  (ii) a request for the provision of more information about events and (iii) a request for information on the themes and actions to be provided in Plain English.

We Did

These issues will be responded to as the Action Plan is taken forward.

We Asked

 

  • Will the draft vision for parenting in Tayside and priorities for parenting help improve the experience of parents and outcomes for  families?
  • Is the draft Tayside Strategy for Parents focused on the things that you think we can do together to make the biggest difference?

You Said

The strategy is focusing on things that are important to you as parents. The four priorities identified were the most important areas to concentrate on making improvements in. These are:

  • Access to good quality information
  • Communities are inclusive, understand children’s needs and support families to thrive
  • Access to effective services that are delivered by a skilled and confident workforce that value the role of parents
  • Policies that affect family life are supportive and deliver positive outcomes for families

We Did

The consultation informed the development of the Draft Tayside Strategy for Parents 2019-2023.

Please note that the strategy name was changed from the Tayside Parenting Strategy to the Tayside Strategy for Parents, reflecting parental ownership and partnership in it design and delivery.

We undertook further consultation  with parents to find out what was important to them and what improvements were needed in relation to the priority areas.